Hershel Williams grew up on a dairy farm in West Virginia. He tried to enlist in the Marine Corps early in World War II and got turned away for being too short. He joined later, only once the Marines relaxed the height requirement, and eventually trained as a demolitions sergeant, and a flamethrower operator.

A Captain Asked. He Answered in Two Words.

On February 23, 1945, three days into the battle of Iwo Jima, Williams's division was bogged down. American tanks were trying to open a lane through a network of reinforced concrete pillboxes, buried mines, and black volcanic sand, and getting nowhere. The bombs and artillery mostly just kicked sand into the air, and Marines were taking heavy losses trying to advance a few yards at a time.

His captain asked if he could do anything about it. Williams answered, "I'll try." Nobody ordered him forward. He volunteered.

Four Hours, Alone, With a 70-Pound Weapon He Hated

Williams strapped on a flamethrower he would later call a terrible, terrible weapon and went forward, covered by only four riflemen. Two of them wouldn't survive the day. For the next four hours, he ran back and forth between American lines and the enemy pillboxes, repeatedly returning to prepare fresh demolition charges and get another serviced flamethrower before struggling back out, often behind the enemy positions, to take out one bunker after another.

On one occasion, he climbed on top of a pillbox and fed the flamethrower's nozzle straight through its air vent, killing everyone inside and silencing the gun. On another, enemy riflemen charged him with fixed bayonets, trying to stop him at close range. He destroyed them with a burst of flame instead. By the time the four hours ended, he'd knocked out roughly seven pillboxes, virtually alone.

What Actually Happened in Those Four Hours

Most retellings compress this into one image: a Marine with a flamethrower clearing pillboxes. But this wasn't one continuous act of courage. It was multiple separate decisions to go back out, made over and over, each one with full knowledge of exactly what the last trip had already cost.

Every return to the rear was a chance to stop. Nobody would have second-guessed him for staying back after the first pillbox, or the third, or the fifth. He didn't have a single moment of bravery to sustain him through four hours. He had to keep choosing it, trip after trip, long after the adrenaline of the first charge had worn off and the exhaustion had set in.

Hershel Williams refused to quit until the job was done.

A Devotion to Duty

Williams's Medal of Honor citation credits his "aggressive fighting spirit and valiant devotion to duty" for sustaining him through the entire action. That phrase, devotion to duty … Not devotion to glory. Not devotion to the mission in some abstract sense. Devotion to what the moment required of him, specifically, repeated until the job was actually finished.

Williams was wounded by shrapnel less than two weeks later and pulled from the fighting. He received the Medal of Honor from President Truman that October. And the war didn't leave him cleanly. He struggled with what would now be recognized as PTSD for years afterward, until he found steadiness in his faith in the 1960s. He went on to serve as chaplain for the Medal of Honor Society for more than three decades, and later founded a foundation supporting Gold Star families.

Duty, in his case, didn't end on Iwo Jima. It just changed shape, decade after decade, for the rest of his life.

Getting Clear on What Duty Actually Requires

Most leaders think about duty the way most people think about heroism: as a single decisive moment they either rise to or don't. Williams's story argues against that framing entirely. Duty showed up as dozens of separate choices at Iwo Jima, and then as decades of separate choices afterward.

Anything is possible with great leadership. And great leaders get clear on their duty before the pressure shows up.

Williams didn't discover his devotion to duty in the middle of that four-hour fight. He'd already decided, long before his captain ever asked the question, what kind of answer he was going to give.

You will likely never face anything close to what Williams faced that day. You will face smaller versions of the same test, over and over, the same way he did. The second time you have to have the hard conversation you already had once. The third time you have to hold a standard you already held twice before and would rather let slide today.

This is the same pattern I wrote about with Audie Murphy at Holtzwihr — that hour on the burning tank destroyer wasn't one decision. It was the same decision, held for sixty straight minutes, remade every time he had a clear excuse to climb down and didn't. Williams ran that same math for four hours, trip after trip back to the pillboxes, each one made with full knowledge of what was waiting — because he'd already decided the answer before the first trip ever started.

Marching Orders

If you want to get clear on your own duty, take the free 3-minute leadership assessment. Your mission starts here.